Every founder has a version of this story. Mine is that we launched a product on the market, customers bought it, and then we learned it was underdosed.
We make a single-serve creatine and electrolyte stick. Creatine has a number attached to it that people in the category know by heart: 5 grams. That is the dose the research is built around, and the dose serious buyers check for. We shipped below it.
Nobody caught it in formulation review. Customers caught it. They read the panel, did the math, and told us.
Here is what we did next, and what I would tell any owner who finds a real flaw in something they are already shipping.
The Instinct to Pause Sales is Usually Wrong
My first reaction was to stop selling until the new formula was ready. That felt like the honest thing to do.
It was not. It was the dramatic thing to do, which is not the same thing.
Pausing would have cost us the revenue that funds the reformulation, broken the sales history that platforms use to rank you, and told every customer who had already bought that they had bought something defective. None of that makes the product better. It just makes the founder feel cleaner.
The real question is not whether to pause. It is whether what you are currently shipping is harmful, illegal, or misrepresented. Those three get you an immediate stop. Everything else is a product that is worse than it should be, which is a different and much more common problem.
Ours was worse than it should be. But it was none of the three. So, we kept selling and fixed it in parallel.
Three Questions Before You Change Anything
We answered these in order, and the order mattered.
Is the claim on the package still true? This is the line you cannot cross. If your label or your ads say something the product does not do, you are not managing a quality problem anymore. The FTC’s Advertising FAQ’s: A Guide for Small Business is worth 20 minutes of any owner’s time here, because it is specific about needing a reasonable basis for a claim before you run it, not after. We checked every claim against the actual panel. They held. The product was weaker than our buyers wanted, not different from what we said it was. That distinction decided everything that followed.
What does the fix actually cost, all in? Not the ingredient cost. The real number includes new packaging, a new production run, the inventory you are still holding, and the weeks of your own attention. For us, the ingredient change was the cheap part, and the packaging was not. Owners routinely underestimate this and then stall halfway through, which is the worst place to stop.
Can you sell through the old inventory honestly, or do you have to eat it? We could, because the claims held. If they had not, we would have been writing off stock. Decide this before you order the new run, because it changes how much you can afford to order.
What We Told Customers, and What We Did Not
We told the people who raised it that they were right, that we were changing the formula, and roughly when.
We did not send a company-wide announcement explaining our mistake to people who had not noticed it. I went back and forth on that one, and I still think we landed in the right place. A mass email framing your own product as having been inadequate turns a quality improvement into a trust event for thousands of customers who were perfectly happy. The people who cared had already written to us. Those are the ones who deserved a direct answer, and they got one.
The test I used: Would I be comfortable if any one of these customers read every word I wrote to every other customer? Yes. Nothing we said to one person contradicted what we said to another. That is the actual standard, not sheer volume of disclosure.
The Cost Was Mostly Time, and Time Is The Part You Cannot Buy Back
The money was survivable. We absorbed the reformulation rather than passing it through to price, because raising price while admitting the product had been weak is a combination no customer forgives.
The expensive part was the calendar. Every week spent on the fix was a week not spent on acquisition, and we were doing it in the run-up to our biggest quarter. If you find your flaw in September, you are fixing it with fourth-quarter money and fourth-quarter attention. That is the hidden cost, and it shows up in no spreadsheet.
Which leads to the thing I would actually change.
What I Would Do Differently
I would have paid someone outside the company to read the panel before launch.
We had reviewed that formulation many times. Everyone who looked at it already knew what it was supposed to be, which is exactly why nobody saw what it was. A person who knows your category and has no stake in your launch will find in 10 minutes what your own team will miss for months. That is a cheap hour, and we did not buy it.
The second thing: I would have written down the number that mattered. Not the full spec. The one figure a buyer in our category checks first. Had “5 grams” been on a single sheet of paper taped to the wall, the gap would have been obvious to anyone walking past it.
Most small companies have a version of that number. Very few have it written anywhere.
Going Into the Season With a Short Record
Small Business Saturday falls on November 28 this year, and for a lot of small brands the next weeks decide the year. We are going into it with a product that is right and a public record of having gotten it wrong, which is a stranger position than it sounds.
It has turned out to be a reasonable place to stand. Buyers in a category full of overclaiming are not really looking for brands that never made a mistake. They are looking for the ones whose numbers they can check. Ours can now be checked, and the account of how we got there is more persuasive than any launch announcement would have been.
If you are sitting on something you know is not right, the fix is almost never as expensive as the delay. The delay is the part that compounds.
Kris Wilkins is CEO and co-founder of Stacked Fitness Hydration, which makes TONE, a single-serve creatine and electrolyte stick. If you are working through a reformulation or a product fix of your own, he is glad to compare notes at drinkstacked.com. On social: @drinkstacked.
Photo courtesy Stacked Fitness Hydration

