Having a great business idea is one thing. Turning it into a successful business is another. And convincing other people to invest in it, buy it, or support it? That’s a challenge all its own.
Several months ago, at Alibaba’s CoCreate event in Los Angeles, I attended a session called “Perfect Your Pitch,” featuring Barry Poznick, a veteran television developer who helped develop Shark Tank. Over the years, I’ve heard plenty of advice about pitching business ideas, but Poznick introduced me to a concept I hadn’t encountered before — the Idea Maze.
Poznick has spent his career evaluating ideas and figuring out which ones have the potential to succeed. And although his experience is rooted in the entertainment industry, his approach is just as relevant to entrepreneurs launching businesses, introducing products, or looking for ways to grow. The Idea Maze provides a framework for taking an idea from its earliest stages and turning it into something that can succeed in the marketplace.
Great Ideas Don’t Start Out Great
One of Poznick’s central messages was that ideas need to evolve. If your original idea hasn’t changed as you’ve worked on it, you may not have challenged it enough.
Getting from a good idea to a great one takes work. It requires questioning your assumptions, identifying weaknesses, and being willing to change direction when something isn’t working.
That’s where the Idea Maze comes in.
My friend and fellow small business advocate Brian Moran attended the same session and took considerably better notes than I did. (Thanks, Brian!)
As Brian explained in his LinkedIn post after the event, Poznick’s framework takes an idea through seven distinct “hallways.” Each one helps determine whether the concept has what it takes to succeed.
The 7 Hallways of the Idea Maze
- Problem. What problem does your idea solve? Before you worry about how to market or sell something, you need to understand why customers would want it in the first place.
- Originality. What makes your idea different? Poznick describes originality as “familiar with a twist.” You don’t necessarily have to invent something entirely new. Sometimes the best opportunities come from improving something customers already understand.
- Participation. How will customers engage with your idea? Today’s consumers don’t necessarily want to be passive buyers. They want experiences, connections, and products worth talking about.
- Emotional connection. Does your idea make people feel something? Customers may try a product because it solves a problem, but emotional connections can help turn first-time buyers into loyal customers.
- Globality. Can the concept travel beyond its original market? Not every small business needs international customers, but it’s worth considering whether an idea has appeal beyond its initial audience.
- Economics. Can the idea make money? This may seem obvious, but enthusiasm for an idea doesn’t guarantee profitability. Poznick shared a lesson from a costly mistake: A great concept and a profitable business are two separate requirements.
- Longevity. Does the idea have staying power? Can it remain relevant as customers, competitors, and markets change? Poznick pointed to the enduring success of Survivoras an example of a concept that continues to attract audiences decades after its debut.
The important thing, according to Poznick, is that you can’t cheat the maze.
If your idea runs into a wall, you can’t simply ignore the problem and move on. You need to back up, rethink your approach, and do the work necessary to get through that part of the process.
And sometimes the right answer is to put an idea aside. That doesn’t necessarily mean abandoning it forever. A concept that isn’t right for today’s market may find its opportunity later.
What Shark Tank Can Teach You About Pitching
Poznick also shared insights from his experience with Shark Tank, where entrepreneurs have only a short time to convince investors that their businesses deserve attention.
He identified three common reasons pitches fail:
- The idea is too early in development. Entrepreneurs haven’t done enough work to demonstrate that their concept is ready.
- They haven’t done their homework. They don’t know enough about their customers, competitors, or business economics.
- They overestimate the market. They assume far more people will buy their products than the evidence supports.
These mistakes aren’t limited to entrepreneurs seeking investors. They can hurt anyone trying to persuade a lender, potential partner, or customer to take a chance on a business.
Poznick’s advice was to start by clarifying your idea into one sentence.
That sounds simple, but it isn’t always easy. If you can’t explain what your business does and why it matters in a single, understandable sentence, you may not yet have a clear enough concept.
But clarity alone isn’t sufficient. Your pitch also needs to connect with people emotionally.
Are You Building a Business or a Brand?
Another interesting point from the presentation was the difference between building a business and building a brand. In his post, Moran highlighted an example Poznick shared from Seth Godin: Hyatt and Nike.
If Hyatt introduced a line of sneakers, would consumers immediately know what to expect? Probably not. But if Nike opened a hotel, people would likely have an immediate impression of what that experience might be like.
Both are successful companies. The difference is that Nike has built a brand identity that people can imagine extending into entirely different categories.
For small business owners, the lesson isn’t that you need to become the next Nike. It’s that you should think about what customers associate with your business beyond the specific products or services you sell.
A strong brand gives people a reason to remember you, recommend you, and return to your business.
Don’t Fall in Love With Your Idea
One of the biggest mistakes entrepreneurs make is falling so deeply in love with an idea that they stop questioning it. But enthusiasm isn’t market research. And a compelling pitch can’t compensate for a business concept that hasn’t been thoroughly tested.
What I liked most about Poznick’s Idea Maze is that it encourages entrepreneurs to do the difficult work before they start selling their ideas to others.
Ask yourself whether you’re solving a real problem, whether customers will care, whether the economics work, and whether the business has room to grow.
Then try explaining your idea in one sentence.
If you can’t, keep working on it.
Because the goal isn’t simply to deliver a great pitch. It’s to build something worth pitching.
Rieva Lesonsky is the founder of Small Business Currents, a content company focusing on small businesses and entrepreneurship. You can find her on Twitter @Rieva, Bluesky @Rieva.bsky.social, and LinkedIn. Or email her at Rieva@SmallBusinessCurrents.com.
Photo courtesy Alibaba.com

